Logic and the Art of
Speaking
"Argument":
Bob: The death penalty is
immoral.
Susan: No, it isn't.
Bob: Yes, it is! Judges
who
gve the death penalty should be impeached.
Susan: You don't even know how the death
penalty
is decided.
Bob: I know a lot more
than
you do.
Susan: I can't talk to you; you are a idiot.
Definition:
Logic is the study of the
methods
and principles of reasoning.
Premises are assumptions.
An argument uses premises to
support
a conclusion.
A fallacy is a deceptive
argument,
i.e. an argument where the conclusion is not supported by the premises.
Examples:
"Ford makes the best automobile in America. After all, more people
drive
Fords than any other American car."
Premise:
More
people drive Fords than any other American car.
Conclusion: Ford makes the best automobile in
America.
Appeal to Popularity.
"I placed a quartz crystal on my forehead, and in five minutes my
headache
was gone. The crystal made my headache go away."
Premise: 1. I placed a quartz crystal on
my forehead.
2. In five minutes my headache was gone.
Conclusion: The crystal made my headache go
away.
False Cause
"Scientists have not found any concrete evidence od aliens visiting
Earth.Therefore, anyone who claims to have seen a UFO must be
hallucinating."
Premise: There is no
proof
that aliens visited the Earth.
Conclusion: Aliens have not visited Earth.
Appeal to Ignorance
"On my travel in Scotland I saw black sheep out of the train window.
All sheep in Scotland are black"
Premise: On my
travel
in Scotland I saw black sheep out of the train window.
Conclusion: All sheep in Scotland are
black.
Hasty Generalization
"You don't support the President, so you are not a patriotic
American."
Premise: You
don't support the President.
Conclusion: You are not a patriotic
American.
Limited Choice (or False Dilemma)
In a commercial for Michelin tires, a picture of a baby is shown
with
the words "because so much is riding on your tires".
Premise: You love
your baby.
Conclusion: You should buy Michelin tires.
Appeal to Emotion
Gwen: You should stop
drinking,
because it's hurting your grades, endangering people when you drink and
drive, and destroying your relationship with your family.
Merle: I've seen you drink
a few too much on occasion myself!
Premise:
Gwen
occasionally drinks too much.
Conclusion: Whatever Gwen says about drinking is
false.
Personal Attack
"Society has an obligation to shelter the homeless because the needy
have a right to the resources of the community."
Premise:
The needy have a right to the resources of the community.
Conclusion: Society has an obligation to
shelter
the homeless.
Circular Reasoning
"We should not continue to fund genetic research because there are
so many ethical issues involved. Ethics is at the heart of our society,
and we cannot afford to have too may ethical loose ends."
Premise:
Genetics
funding is related to ethics. And here is an argument relating to
ethics:
"Ethics is at the heart of our society, and we cannot afford to have too
may ethical loose ends."
Conclusion: We should not continue to fund genetic
research.
Diversion (Red Herring)
Columnist William F. Buckley has written many articles arguing in
favor
of legalizing drugs. A speaker who opposes legalization begins by
stating,"Mr.
Buckley doesn't think there's anything wrong with drug use, but I do."
Analysis: Mr Buckley does not advocate drug use. His
argument
may be based on reasons like the crime rate, the cost of policing and
the
consistency of and respect for the law.
The speaker misrepresents Mr Buckley and then proceeds to knock down
the distorted argument.
Straw Man
and then there are variations:
-
appeal to authority: A
is an authority on the subject and A says p is true, therefore p is
true.
-
appeal to belief, tradition, common
practice,
-
appeal to force (consequences): do
it or else (there might be disagreeable consequences).
-
division: if p is true for combined
entity A, it must be true for all its component pieces.(this is a
generalization
of hasty generalization)
-
slippery slope: Event X has occurred
(or will or might occur), therefore event Y will inevitably
happen.
(this is a generalization of false cause)
-
special pleading: Person A
accepts
standard(s) S and applies them to others in circumtance(s) C, Person A
is in circumstance(s) C, therefore A is exempt from S.
-
two wrongs make a right: It is
claimed
that person B would do X to person A, thus it is acceptable for person
A to do X to person B (when A's doing X to B is not necessary to prevent
B from doing X to A).
-
prejudicial language: loaded or
emotive
terms are used to attach value or moral goodness to believing the
proposition
or suspicion or dislike to the opposing position.
-
weak analogy: Many arguments rely on
an analogy between two or more objects, ideas, or situations. If the two
things that are being compared aren't really alike in the relevant
respects,
the analogy is a weak one, and the argument that relies on it commits
the
fallacy of weak analogy.
-
equivocation: is a sliding between
two or more different meanings of a single word or phrase that is
important
to the argument
-
complex question: Two otherwise
unrelated
points are treated as a single proposition. The reader is expected to
accept
or reject both together, when in reality one may be acceptable while the
other is not. A complex question is an illegitimate use of the "and"
operator.
Examples:
-
"My roommate said her philosophy class was hard, and the one I'm in is
hard, too. All philosophy classes must be hard!"
-
"The seriousness of a punishment should match the seriousness of the
crime.
Right now, the punishment for drunk driving may simply be a fine. But
drunk
driving is a very serious crime that can kill innocent people. So the
death
penalty should be the punishment for drunk driving."
-
"Gay marriages are just immoral. 70% of Americans think so!"
-
America: love it or leave it.
-
Since scientists have not proven that global warming will occur,
therefore
it won't.
-
"We should abolish the death penalty. Many respected people, such as
actor
Guy Handsome, have publicly stated their opposition to it."
-
"President Jones raised taxes, and then the rate of violent crime went
up. Jones is responsible for the rise in crime."/
-
-
"Andrea Dworkin has written several books arguing that pornography harms
women. But Dworkin is an ugly, bitter person, so you shouldn't listen to
her."
-
The defendant ought to be found innocent because if he isn't, there will
be a riot and many innocent citizens will be hurt or killed.
-
"Guns are like hammers.they're both tools with metal parts that could be
used to kill someone. And yet it would be ridiculous to restrict the
purchase
of hammers.so restrictions on purchasing guns are equally
ridiculous."
-
"People have been trying for centuries to prove that God exists. But no
one has yet been able to prove it. Therefore, God does not exist."
-
"Feminists want to ban all pornography and punish everyone who reads it!
But such harsh measures are surely inappropriate, so the feminists are
wrong: porn and its readers should be left in peace."
-
You say I should give up alcohol, but you haven't been sober for more
than
a year yourself.
-
Have you stopped beating your wife?
-
"You know, I've begun to think that there is some merit in the
Republican's
tax cut plan. I suggest that you come up with something like it, because
If we Democrats are going to survive as a party, we have got to show
that
we are as tough-minded as the Republicans, since that is what the public
wants."
-
".[N]ot one of 800 sexologists at a recent conference raised a hand when
asked if they would trust a thin rubber sheath to protect them during
intercourse
with a known HIV infected person. . And yet they're perfectly willing to
tell our kids that "safe sex" is within reach and that they can sleep
around
with impunity."(James Dobson)
-
The proposal is likely to be resisted by the bureaucrats on Capitol
Hill.
-
"Animal experimentation reduces our respect for life. If we don't
respect
life, we are likely to be more and more tolerant of violent acts like
war
and murder. Soon our society will become a battlefield in which everyone
constantly fears for their lives. It will be the end of civilization. To
prevent this terrible consequence, we should make animal experimentation
illegal right now."
-
"Giving money to charity is the right thing to do. So charities have a
right to our money."
-
"Caldwell Hall is in bad shape. Either we tear it down and put up a new
building, or we continue to risk students' safety. Obviously we
shouldn't
risk anyone's safety, so we must tear the building down."
-
"If I fail English 101, I won't be able to graduate. If I don't
graduate,
I probably won't be able to get a good job, and I may very well end up
doing temp work or flipping burgers for the next year."
-
"Active euthanasia is morally acceptable. It is a decent, ethical thing
to help another human being escape suffering through death."
-
You should never gamble. Once you start gambling you find it hard to
stop.
Soon you are spending all your money on gambling, and eventually you
will
turn to crime to support your earnings.
-
Do you support freedom and the right to bear arms?
-
You had better agree that the new company policy is the best if you
expect
to keep your job.
-
You ALWAYS win these arguments. Can't you let me win just this
once?
-
You must believe in God, otherwise life would have no meaning.
-
Not only is paying a higher income tax a patriotic duty, it is also a
sacred
obligation.
-
Everyone knows that the Earth is flat, so why do you persist in your
outlandish
claims?
-
We should disregard Fred's argument because he is just angry about the
fact that defendant once cheated him out of $100.
-
"I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for
the
graduate students. I recommend that you support it, too. After all, we
are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected."
Common Fallacy Types - Overview
appeal to popularity |
diversion |
slippery slope |
false cause |
straw man |
special pleading |
appeal to ignorance |
appeal to authority |
two wrongs make a right |
hasty generalization |
appeal to belief |
prejudicial language |
limited choice |
appeal to tradition |
weak analogy |
appeal to emotion |
appeal to common practice |
equivocation |
circular reasoning |
appeal to force |
complex question |
personal attack |
division |
|